Jamilyn Manning Bernard Holcomb Angela Yam and John Taylor Ward
in Heartbeat Opera's "Orgy and Bess"
We chose to spend our Halloween evening at Judson Memorial Church with Heartbeat Opera at their annual drag show and we are so glad we did. The show succeeded on so many levels we scarcely know where to begin.
If you came to have a riotous good time you would have been titillated by the off-color repartee and private jokes . If you came to hear your favorite arias professionally sung you would have been well satisfied. If you came because you love cleverly snarky dialogue and lyrics you would have left smiling. If you came for the visual impact you would have been thrilled by the costumes.
This annual show is always top notch and this one even outdid prior iterations, thanks to the astute direction of Ethan Heard, the fine singing and acting by the cast, the lavish costuming by David Quinn and the outstanding make up design by Maiko Ando. The script was written by Ethan and Peregrine Heard and Jacob Ashworth.
If outrageous costuming is your thing stop reading and look at our FB and IG entries to see why we were so impressed. Nothing anywhere in NYC could have been as colorful and creative. If you came for the snarky gay humor we wish we had a transcript for you to read. Better yet, you may be able to snag tickets since the show has been extended through next week.
If you are interested in the operatic offerings this is the right place to learn how context is so vital. Arias can be given different shades of meaning by virtue of the setting. Should you be offended by such tinkering, your opinion would have seemed well represented by John Taylor Ward's impression of an opera patroness of the Upper East Side variety. Eventually the hi jinx won her over and she joined in the fun, shedding her pearls and pumps to participate in the foreshadowed orgy. You will not be offended since said orgy takes place behind a white sheet leaving the various shadows to the interpretation of your imagination.
If suffering heroines comprise your operatic taste you might have fixated on Jamilyn Manning's interpretation of Lucia, complete with bloody wedding gown and great big knife. Or you may have preferred the Cio-Cio San of Angela Tam (also a knife-wielder) whose costume echoed contemporary Japanese girl fashions like "decora"and "gyaru". Poor Serena from Porgy and Bess is another suffering heroine and Bernard Holcomb gave her lament "My Man's Gone Now" a unique twist. Multiple pants roles were enacted by Sichel Claverie who, as a male, did not seem to suffer much!
Ears that were attuned to opera were kept entertained, identifying familiar arias and choruses no matter how out of context. A medley of tunes related to Asian inspired operas and musical theater melded Puccini with Gilbert and Sullivan, Rogers and Hammerstein, Schönberg and Boublil. Vastly entertaining in the moment, it did lead to some reflection on the cultural depiction of Asian women from Flower Drum Song to Miss Saigon to Madama Butterfly.
There was a banquet of cleverness that was supported by a deep knowledge of the repertory. We would have loved to have been a fly on the wall during some of the writing sessions but must be content with marveling at the results. Opera lovers must have had a fine time playing "Name that Tune". We are sure most of us picked up on the Wagner, the Verdi (loved the "Anvil Chorus" from Il Trovatore) ,the Donizetti, Bellini, Leoncavallo, Händel, and Orff. We probably missed a few such as Rameau's Les Indes Gallants and The Wiz, neither of which we have seen. And what an astonishment to hear Aretha Franklin's version of "Nessun dorma" performed by Mr. Holcomb.
All of the performances were spot on and, as you can see from the photos, David Quinn's costumes were outstanding, as was Maiko Ando's makeup design. It comes as no surprise that Ethan Heard returned to direct the show; his artistic stamp is always recognizable.
The marvelous musical direction was in the hands of Jacob Ashworth and Dan Schlossberg who played, respectively, violin and piano. Mr. Ashworth made quite an impression as a Valkyrie when he took to the stage after the performance. A guitar and clarinet made up the remainder of the accompaniment and we have nothing but praise for the arrangements.
Although we have occasionally objected to HeartbeatOpera's tampering with the classics, their artistic leanings are always welcome on the occasion of the annual Halloween drag show which we have never missed. Braving the Greenwich Village crowds and transportation snafus seemed a small price to pay for such an evening. It is amazing to know that a collection of musical and visual artists can conspire to produce an impressive evening like that.
We urge you Dear Reader to get tickets for the few remaining shows. Halloween is such a fun holiday that it seems worth extending the celebration of it for another week.
We will close by expressing the wish that the ghost of Al Carmines, the late Minister of Judson Memorial Church, might have visited the church and enjoyed the production. Mr. Carmines was himself a creator of vast talent and filled the church with a succession of original musical theater performances that were our introduction to the art form. On All Saint's Day, the dead are allowed to return to earth and enjoy an ofrenda from the living-- so our fantasy is not so far-fetched! We think of Heartbeat's production as an ofrenda to the spirit of Mr. Carmines. Does anyone still remember him, his warm and loving personality, and his original productions? We know for a fact that the renowned Ira Siff does, since he starred in one.
© meche kroop
