TOYS ARE US

 Anthony Blatter, Shengyang Lin, Carter Bonyeop Gu, Maestro Michael Sakir, Grace Christensen, and Miryoung Song

We just saw a colorful and original performance of Donizetti's charming comedy L'elisir d'amore at Manhattan School of Music, performed by an impressive young cast possessed of fine voices and convincing dramatic ability. The "concept" of Director Katherine M. Carter was surely original and added a quantity of eye candy that at times seemed excessive and distracting. We are familiar with her work and have found it superb at times and puzzling at other times.

Her concept was to set the opera in a child's toy box, a child who seemed to have an excess of toys. This, of course, served to get a lot of students onstage which we do understand and applaud, and it provided an excellent opportunity for Costume Designer Caitlin Cisek and for Loryn Pretorius who designed the clever wigs, hairstyles and makeup.

We are decades past childhood but it seems like centuries. We imagine that children talks to their toys and invent dramatic situations and dialogues for them to participate in and we further imagine (although we have never participated in child psychotherapy) that children work through their problems in such play. So presumably a child might work through problems of jealousy, rejection, and acceptance in romantic love.

Felice Romani's delightful libretto concerns the most important young woman in a village, one who has the benefit of literacy, and her initial rejection of a young man who worships her. A situation is devised in which he manages to win her love when he becomes more romantically desirable and she becomes jealous. This situation seems to us to transcend location and epoch.  The humor of the story comes from the fact that the gullible villagers are cozened by a traveling salesman pretending to be a doctor who peddles a love serum which is actually wine. Who of us has not been "taken in" by influencers online who promise unrealistic remedies?

The young man Nemorino has been recast as a Raggedy Andy doll and tenor Carter Bonyeop Gu used his vocal and dramatic skills to bring the character to vivid life, inviting our understanding of shy but sincere young men who are missing nothing but confidence. For the opera to work the singer must win our affection and our wish for him to succeed. At this, Mr. Choi succeeded admirably. His "Quanto è bella, quanto è cara" told us everything we needed to know about him.

The object of his affection is Adina, here portrayed as a ballerina, played by the adorable soprano Grace Christensen  whose fine flexible instrument was matched by a charming presence. The audience must want to see her feelings transform from indifference to respect. By the end of the opera, her "Prendi, per me sei libero" convinced us of her emotional growth.

The humor comes from the fact that Nemorino believes that Dr. Dulcamara's "love potion" is responsible for his sudden success with women when it is actually the fact that his wealthy uncle has died and he has inherited a fortune. Adina must confront the fact that she might lose him to the crowd of worshipping women.

Of course, there must be a romantic rival and this place is occupied by a military man passing through town. Sergeant Belcore is here played by the fine young baritone Shengyang Lin, costumed as a G.I. Joe doll who preens and struts. his "Come Paride vezzoso" demonstrated his vocal prowess as well as acting chops.

The affable but exploitative Dr. Dulcamara came in his own toy box and was given a fine humorous performance by Anthony Blatter who shone in his duet with Adina "Io son ricco e tu sei bella" in the wedding scene of Act II.

The big aria that we were all waiting for, "Una furtive lagrima", left us a bit disappointed. All through the opera, Mr. Gu's vocalism was beyond admirable and his gestures were entirely on point. However, this final aria was marred a bit by some stock gestures that seemed generic and misplaced according to the text and the vocalism was not as admirable as it was during the rest of the opera. This left us wondering whether he was vocally fatigued or perhaps trying to imitate some famous tenor or maybe he was suffering from a nervous awareness of the importance of the capstone aria.

Miryoung Song gave a fine performance as Gianetta when she tells the villagers about Nemorino's inheritance.

Maestro Michael Sakir's conducting emphasized the lighthearted nature of this opera buffa and the performance elicited from the MSM orchestra members was nothing short of wonderful.   James Rotondo's set design was apropos to the story. We particularly liked the figure of Dr. Dulcamara emerging from a toy box.

In terms of the direction, we felt the cleverness exceeded desirable limits. When there is much cavorting onstage that detracts from the singing we feel unhappy. This is opera not film, and we want to focus on the voices. The concept was not a poor one but the execution was excessive. We have written about Ms. Carter's direction on a few prior occasions and have admired her imagination and also deplored liberties of time and place that seemed irrationally taken.

We found the costuming of Caitlin Cisek to be colorful and varied and the hairstylings, wigs, and makeup of Loryn Pretorius to be outstanding.

In conclusion, we found our evening with Manhattan School of Music Graduate Opera Theatre to be well spent.

© meche kroop