LINDEMANN RECITAL

Julia Pilant and Petr Nekoranec

For those of you who don't know, the Lindemann Young Artist Development Program was created in 1980 by James Levine to identify and develop extraordinarily talented young singers, coaches, and pianists. Those fortunate enough to get accepted have access to all the resources of The Metropolitan Opera and, since 2010, to Juilliard School as well. These young artists are in demand all over the world, as well as onstage at the Met.

Friday evening was spent at the Bruno Walter Auditorium to enjoy one of their recitals. We went for the voices and the voice that captured our attention first was that of the French horn. We have always loved the sound and getting up close and personal for the first time allowed us to see how vocal an instrument it is and how sensitive. Valves must be removed and drained, for example. To play it is difficult.  To play it well is quite a gift.

The recital opened with Britten's Serenade for Tenor, Horn, and Strings, Op. 31--with nary a string in sight. Apparently someone who was uncredited in the program had arranged it for tenor, horn, and piano. We had no interest in the text but we surely did enjoy the artistry of the performance. The work is moody and elegiac but is punctuated by muted announcements from the horn, which brought the work to life. For the Epilogue, the horn was heard from offstage, a very special moment. 

Petr Nekoranec, in his first year of the Lindemann Young Artist Development Program is the possessor of exactly the type of tenor we most enjoy. It is a sweet sound but with a rich texture; moreover his English diction (thanks to English Instructor Patricia Brandt and coach Jocelyn Dueck) is exemplary and puts to shame that of native American speakers. We enjoyed the melismatic passages of the Sonnet movement.

Giuseppe Mentuccia's piano wove together the voice and the horn and the entire work was well-balanced. We are looking forward to hearing Mr. Nekoranec sing a work in which we can appreciate the unique qualities of his voice. We imagine that Dvorak's songs would be lovely. 

The program for this recital was a challenging one, both for the artists and the audience. We are sure there were people in the hall who enjoy Olivier Messiaen but we are not among them. There are works that grow on you with repeated exposure and there are works that never capture one's affection. Poemes pour Mi are in the latter category.

That being said, The composer's sincerity was matched by the equally sincere performance of soprano Clarissa Lyons. She sang with fine French diction  and made sense of the text which she had translated herself. Fortunately she appeared later in the program singing Joseph Haydn's concert aria "Berenice che fai", a passionate work with different colors in each section. Her voice is well centered from top to bottom and beautifully phrased. It was altogether a polished performance with excellent support from pianist Valeriya Polunina who has a delicate touch.

The third pair of artists on the program comprised tenor Ian Koziara with pianist Zalman Kelber. Uh oh! More Britten! On This Island is another work we are not adding to our hit parade. Mr. Koziara has a large powerful dramatic tenor with plenty of strength in the lower register. We would have liked to hear him sing some Verdi. Mr. Kelber's piano was insistent in "Now the leaves are falling fast" and gently rippling in "Seascape".  Perhaps "Nocturne" had the loveliest melody.

As far as 20th c. music goes, Frank Bridge's setting of Mary Coleridge's "Love went a-riding" was unusually accessible and pleasing to the ear.  For Wagner's "Traume", one of the Wesendonck Lieder, we would have preferred a lighter vocal touch. There is plenty of Wagner more suited to such a hearty voice.

(c) meche kroop

NO SLEEPWALKING HERE!

Hyesang Park and Kang Wang (photo by Nan Melville)

Initially, we felt a trifle disappointed that Juilliard Opera would be presenting Bellini's La sonnambula in a semi-staged version, hoping to see a production that would wipe from our memory the overly complicated production at the Metropolitan Opera. Within the first few minutes we recognized that the performances themselves created the set and the action, much the way that mountains create their own weather.

With flawless conducting, instrumentalism, and vocal performance, this was a knockout production of which Bellini would have been very proud. It is well known how important to Bellini was the casting.

Two star sopranos took the stage last night and showed their mettle as masters of bel canto style. As Amina, we heard Hyesang Park, who first impressed us exactly two years ago when she performed the famous aria from this selfsame opera "Ah, non credea mirarti" in a master class with Renée Fleming. Clearly she has been working on this role for some time and appeared to inhabit it with ease.

Here, she had the opportunity to portray the modest and innocent Amina, in contrast with the flirtatious Florilla she portrayed in Rossini's Il turco in Italia. She colored her bright voice just right for the role, sounding as young and innocent as the character is meant to be. Her command of the trills, swoops, turns and other embellishments was definitive. Her petite stature abetted the characterization.

Clarissa Lyons was equally impressive as Lisa. We were introduced to this statuesque beauty last month at one of Marilyn Horne's Spotlight Recitals (all these reviews are archived and available through the search bar). It was exciting to see what she can do on an opera stage with her expressive instrument, splendid technique, and fine acting.

We have always found Elvino to be an unlikeable character by dint of his inconstancy. He abandoned Lisa for Amina and was ready to abandon Amina for Lisa when he suspected Amina of infidelity. But his arias and duets are divine, so we can forgive his fickleness! Last night the excellent tenor Kang Wang turned in a fine performance. His instrument is larger and darker than one would expect in this role but he handled it beautifully and musically.

Much of the plot hangs on the shoulders of the mysterious Count Rodolfo who appears in the Swiss town where he grew up and manages to restore sanity to the superstitious townfolk who think the sleepwalking Amina is a ghost. He must convince Elvino that Amina's presence in his room was innocent, as indeed it was.

On the broad shoulders of bass Sava Vemič rested this task and he acquitted himself admirably, as he always does. He has a wonderful instrument that can only grow with the years and the physical presence to assume a variety of roles in that fach.

We have always read between the lines of Felice Romani's libretto. If the Count observes that Amina bears a strong resemblance to a woman he once loved, and if he restrains himself from taking advantage of her sleepwalking into his room at the inn, and if he defends her honor vigorously, isn't it possible that he is her father?

We have never read the play by Eugène Scribe nor have we seen the ballet on which the opera is based, so we have made up the backstory for ourselves. "The Count got a local girl pregnant and disappeared. The woman died in childbirth and Teresa adopted her". Seeing some of this "backstory" acknowledged in the program notes gave us quite a sense of satisfaction!

As Lisa's rejected suitor, bass-baritone Thesele Kemane managed to be both ridiculous and touching. We look forward to hearing more of him.

Tenor Miles Mykkanen excels at putting a personal spin on a great variety of roles and last night he took the role of the Notary which offered little room for characterization but space to appreciate his characteristic sound.

Mezzo-soprano Sara Couden sang the part of Teresa, Amina's caring and protecting mother.

On the podium we had the compelling conductor Speranza Scappucci whom we always admire. She is one of those conductors who uses her entire body to elicit what she wants from the orchestra and The Juilliard Orchestra gave her exactly what she wanted.

The balance was perfect, particularly between the orchestra and the off-stage musicians. The woodwinds made a particularly fine showing and cellist Philip Sheegog's duet with Ms. Park was exquisite. Maybe not as terrifying as Lucia's mad scene with the glass harp but replete with gorgeous harmonies.

As noted above, the artists created the set, so to speak, but Kate Ashton's lighting design surely helped things along. There was one dramatic shift of lighting that deftly underscored the shift in the plot.

David Paul was dramatic consultant.

The chorus of townsfolk supported the action beautifully.

There was a moment when the townsfolk onstage were riveted by the apparition of Lisa sleepwalking. Elvino, the Count, Lisa, and Theresa seemed spellbound. This was a perfect parallel to the audience's rapt attention to the stage.

This production was a product of the fruitful partnership between Juilliard Opera and The Metropolitan Opera's Lindemann Young Artist Development Program. 

(c) meche kroop