Maureen Zoltek and Erin Wagner
Having won the Naumburg Vocal Award in 2021, the impressive mezzo-soprano Erin Wagner presented a stunning recital at Manhattan School of Music, from which she received her BM in 2019. She was accompanied by the equally impressive collaborative pianist Maureen Zoltek who received her DMA from the same institution in 2013. The two artists did credit to their alma mater and to the Naumburg Foundation.
The recital was a very personal one. Ms. Wagner has strong tastes about what she wants to present and how she does so. She opened the program with Hugo Wolf's 1888 setting of the Mignon Lieder, taken from Goethe's Wilhelm Meisters Leehrjahre. We are mostly familiar with the setting by Schubert and it was a challenge to wipe those easy Schubertian melodies from our brain and open our ear to the more difficult harmonies of Wolf. Will we ever be able to really hear the settings by Schumann and Tchaikovsky? The text is so compelling that it is a wonder that more composers have not made the attempt but we are glad of it. In perfect German and with deep emotion, Ms. Wagner brought this sad tale to vivid life.
Next on the program was a contemporary work, a setting of text of Larry Eigner by David Clay Metten. In the program notes, Ms. Wagner described her connection with both poet and composer and the personal involvement was clear. Nonetheless, we found nothing in the text or vocal line to relate to and shifted our attention to the piano. Ms. Zoltek is a remarkable pianist and tackled the challenging and varied piano part with relish. We might add that her erect posture and graceful arms added to our fascination.
The first half of the program jumped from the 19th century to the 21st but the second half brought us to the 20th century with a late life composition by Francis Poulenc, one that we always enjoy hearing--the intensely dramatic "La dame de Monte Carlo" which gave Ms. Wagner an opportunity to let out all the stops dramatically, creating a character and telling her story in as fine a French as one could wish for.
The program concluded with Samuel Barber's Hermit Songs of 1953. This collection of ten songs represents texts casually inscribed by medieval monks. And what a collection it is! Some of the texts are sacred ("St. Ita's Vision", "The Praises of God", "The Crucifixion") and some are profane ("Promiscuity") and some are just charming and worldly ("The Monk and His Cat"). It seems likely that the authors of the text were different men with different moods and Ms. Wagner gave each writer his due.
The audience demanded an encore and we got one--"Sure on this Shining Night", a Barber setting of text by James Agee.
We have been writing about Ms. Wagner for at least six years and have witnessed her winning one competition after another. She continues to surprise us and we are willing to follow where she leads. We have said nothing this time about her vocal and linguistic strengths but they are legendary. If you wish to appreciate her growth as an artist, we urge you to enter her name in the search bar so you can catch up.
© meche kroop
