MISSION

We are here to encourage the development of gifted young singers and to stimulate the growth of New York City's invaluable chamber opera companies. But we will not neglect the Metropolitan Opera either. Get ready for bouquets and brickbats.
Showing posts with label Charles Styles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charles Styles. Show all posts

Friday, November 20, 2026

SINGERS SHINE BUT FLOYD FLUBS


 Vanessa Isiguen and Markel Reed
(photo by Russ Rowland)

Director Philip Schneidman seems to love Carlisle Floyd. We love the Little Opera Theatre of New York but we don't love Carlisle Floyd, no matter how often we have tried.  For the most part we have tried because we admire LOTNY for the excellence of their productions, many of which we have enjoyed, going back over a decade. Our favorite was Prince of Players which, we believe, was Floyd's last opera, written in the 21st century, and somewhat more melodic than his others.

Floyd's Wuthering Heights was commissioned by the Santa Fe Opera in the mid 20th century, rewritten shortly thereafter for the New York City Opera, and has gone unperformed and nearly forgotten for three-quarters of a century.

Floyd liked to write his own libretti and seems to be very well thought of by fans of 20th century opera, a group of which we are not a member. Our ears search in vain for a melody with none to be found. Last night we attended LOTNY's production of Floyd's Wuthering Heights, the libretto of which he adapted from  Emily Brontë's lengthy and dense novel of a century earlier, at least from the first half of the novel. In his iteration, Cathy dies childless so we know there will not be a sequel. That's fine with us!

Let it be said right away that the episodic scenes were dramatically interesting and well staged by Mr. Schneidman, with period accurate costuming by Lara De Bruijn and simple yet functional set design by Claire Karoff. Let it also be noted that the performances were exemplary in terms of acting. With regard to the singing, whenever the dense brass-heavy orchestration permitted the voices to be appreciated, we were not disappointed. 

As a matter of fact, the three important female roles were taken by three superb singers, all of whom we have written about quite a bit, going back over a decade.  The role of Cathy was given to soprano Vanessa Isiguen whom we recently heard as La Catrina in El Ultimo Sueno de Frida y Diego. However, our admiration for her vocal gifts goes back to her undergraduate days at Mannes College for Music when we heard her Cio-Cio San, and also a Mimi for the Marcello Giordani Foundation. Regular readers will recall the pleasure we get from witnessing a singer's hard-earned success.

Another case in point is soprano Elizabeth Novella who portrayed Isabella. The first time we heard her was as Hänsel und Gretel's stepmother at Manhattan School of Music; the last time we heard her was as a highly polished Donna Anna with Teatro Nuovo. Another remarkable career triumph to celebrate!

And what about mezzo-soprano Jana Kellerman! We have watched her over the last decade taking a variety of roles with New Amsterdam Opera and doing them all justice. Her assumption of the role of Nelly in the Floyd opera was dramatically convincing and much of her dialogue was comprehensible due to good diction and the lower tessitura.

The male singers were also excellent. Baritone Markel Reed could often be heard above the orchestra and did a fine job convincing us of Heathcliff's transformation. Tenor Charles Styles served well as Edgar Linton, as did Tom Walters as Hindley.

Conductor Richard Cordova seemed a lot fonder of Floyd's music than we were. Part of the problem for us was that we were seated adjacent to the brass and the percussion sections, which included kettle drums and cymbals. So, we have no idea what the orchestral balance was like in the middle of the small theater at The Sheen Center. Adding to the sonic overwhelm is the fact that the orchestra is seated at the same level as the audience with the stage elevated. We might have had a very different experience had we been seated near the strings.

Nonetheless, we often felt as if the texture of the orchestral writing was not congruent with the action onstage. There was one aria for Isabella for which the texture lightened up a bit but most of the writing seemed bombastic. Nothing suggested the misty moors of Yorkshire, only the bad weather. Yes, the relationship between Cathy and Heathcliff was turbulent but there were also tender moments and our ears longed for some tender music.

Given that English is such a difficult language to sing, especially incomprehensible at the upper half of the vocal range, titles would have been most welcome. There was a projection system which announced the time and place of each scene; it could have been put to good use showing the dialogue. The printed program had only the most cursory summary.

If you, Dear Reader, enjoy 20th century opera, by all means you should catch this production There are two casts and our knowledge of the other cast indicates that you will enjoy either cast. Just don't sit on the right side of the theater!

© meche kroop